Great prices of rare beanie babies and related products. Shop rare beanie babies now! Shop Rare Beanie Babies from Ebay.com.

Ty Beanie Babies Peace Bear Retired Mwmt W Rare Errors

Ty Beanie Babies Peace Bear Retired Mwmt W Rare Errors

$2,459.00

Rare Retired Ty Beanie Baby 039 Curly 039 The-bear With Many Errors Mint

Rare Retired Ty Beanie Baby 039 Curly 039 The-bear With Many Errors Mint

$2,436.00

Beanie Baby - Kicks -very Rare Versionerrortags

Beanie Baby - Kicks -very Rare Versionerrortags

$2,399.99

Ty Beanie Baby Freckles, Retired 1996, Original, Nwt, Rare

Ty Beanie Baby Freckles, Retired 1996, Original, Nwt, Rare

$2,400.00

Rare Claude The Crab Beanie Baby

Rare Claude The Crab Beanie Baby

$2,400.00

Rare Ty Beanie Baby Peace Bear Original Collectible With Tag Errors

Rare Ty Beanie Baby Peace Bear Original Collectible With Tag Errors

$2,400.00

Ty Beanie Baby Claude The Crab 11 Errors 1996 Extremely Rare

Ty Beanie Baby Claude The Crab 11 Errors 1996 Extremely Rare

$2,400.00

Extremely Rare Ty Beanie Baby Stretch W 2 Wrong Tags  Retired

Extremely Rare Ty Beanie Baby Stretch W 2 Wrong Tags Retired

$2,400.00

Strut Rooster Ty Beanie Baby Origional 1996 Retired Rare 6 Error Odd Collectable

Strut Rooster Ty Beanie Baby Origional 1996 Retired Rare 6 Error Odd Collectable

$2,400.00

Strut Rooster Ty Beanie Baby Origional 1996 Retired Rare 6 Error Odd Collectable

Strut Rooster Ty Beanie Baby Origional 1996 Retired Rare 6 Error Odd Collectable

$2,400.00

Ty Beanie Baby Claude-rare Retired

Ty Beanie Baby Claude-rare Retired

$2,400.00

Ty Beanie Baby Hippity Origiinal 1996 Very Rare, With Many Errors.

Ty Beanie Baby Hippity Origiinal 1996 Very Rare, With Many Errors.

$2,399.00

Beanie Babies-new-never Opened-rare-orginal Box And Receipt -retired All Or One.

Beanie Babies-new-never Opened-rare-orginal Box And Receipt -retired All Or One.

$2,399.00

Rare Ty Beanie Babies Lot Hippity And Hoppity With Multiple Errors, Pvc And Tags

Rare Ty Beanie Babies Lot Hippity And Hoppity With Multiple Errors, Pvc And Tags

$2,395.00

Ty Beanie Baby Top 5 Value 1st Edition Very Rare 1993 Patti Great Condition

Ty Beanie Baby Top 5 Value 1st Edition Very Rare 1993 Patti Great Condition

$2,350.00

Princess Diana Ty Beanie Baby Authenticated Pvc, Super Rare Indonesia

Princess Diana Ty Beanie Baby Authenticated Pvc, Super Rare Indonesia

$2,333.33

Extremely Rare Retired Curly The Bear Original Ty Tag Several Tag Errors

Extremely Rare Retired Curly The Bear Original Ty Tag Several Tag Errors

$2,300.00

Retired No Star Chocolate The Moose Dob 42793 Style 4015 Ultra Rare

Retired No Star Chocolate The Moose Dob 42793 Style 4015 Ultra Rare

$2,299.99

Rare Ty Beanie Baby Fortune With Errors. Retired, Comes With Tag Protector.

Rare Ty Beanie Baby Fortune With Errors. Retired, Comes With Tag Protector.

$2,300.00

Rare Mint Condition Valentina Beanie Baby Tag W Errors

Rare Mint Condition Valentina Beanie Baby Tag W Errors

$2,300.00

Extremely Rare Ty Beanie Baby 'curly' Retired Bear Many Tag Errors Mint 5043200

Extremely Rare Ty Beanie Baby 'curly' Retired Bear Many Tag Errors Mint 5043200

$2,300.00

New Extremely Rare Beanie Baby Mac June 10, 1998

New Extremely Rare Beanie Baby Mac June 10, 1998

$2,290.00

Rare-retired Mcdonalds Beanie Babies 1999 Intl. Lot - All 4 Confirmed Errors

Rare-retired Mcdonalds Beanie Babies 1999 Intl. Lot - All 4 Confirmed Errors

$2,250.00

Rare Peace Beanie Baby Rainbow Colors  Ty

Rare Peace Beanie Baby Rainbow Colors Ty

$2,250.00

Rare, Mint Condition Ty Beanie Baby Valentino With Errors

Rare, Mint Condition Ty Beanie Baby Valentino With Errors

$2,250.00

Mintgarcia Rare Beanie Bear Wall Misprints

Mintgarcia Rare Beanie Bear Wall Misprints

$2,250.00

Ty Beanie Babies Garcia The Bear Rare Misprint Swing Tag And Tush Tag With Pvc

Ty Beanie Babies Garcia The Bear Rare Misprint Swing Tag And Tush Tag With Pvc

$2,250.00

Rare With Multiple Factory Errors Ty Beanie Baby Curly The Bear Pvc Pellets Mint

Rare With Multiple Factory Errors Ty Beanie Baby Curly The Bear Pvc Pellets Mint

$2,250.00

Very Rare 4 Errors Ty Beanie Baby Mac Limiited Edition New Condition

Very Rare 4 Errors Ty Beanie Baby Mac Limiited Edition New Condition

$2,250.00

Very Rare Rover Ty Beanie Baby Retired Original W Many Errors 10 Deutschland

Very Rare Rover Ty Beanie Baby Retired Original W Many Errors 10 Deutschland

$2,249.99

Ty Glory Maple Brittania Erin Set Rare Retired Errors Beanie Bears

Ty Glory Maple Brittania Erin Set Rare Retired Errors Beanie Bears

$2,235.00

Ty Beanie Baby Glory With Tag Errors Mint Condition Rare

Ty Beanie Baby Glory With Tag Errors Mint Condition Rare

$1,600.00

Rare Ty Beanie Baby Chocolate, 1993, Pvc Pellets, Tag Errors, Mwmt

Rare Ty Beanie Baby Chocolate, 1993, Pvc Pellets, Tag Errors, Mwmt

$2,200.00

Rare Ty 19931994 Beanie Baby Daisy Cow Retired Bigger Ear

Rare Ty 19931994 Beanie Baby Daisy Cow Retired Bigger Ear

$1,350.00

Ty Beanie Baby Valentino Very Rare 19931994 Collectible Hang Tag Errors

Ty Beanie Baby Valentino Very Rare 19931994 Collectible Hang Tag Errors

$2,200.00

Extremely Rare Ty Beanie Babie's Peace Bear With 11 Tag Errors Unheard Of ....

Extremely Rare Ty Beanie Babie's Peace Bear With 11 Tag Errors Unheard Of ....

$2,200.00

1996 Rare Peace Original Mint Tag Errors Beanie Babies

1996 Rare Peace Original Mint Tag Errors Beanie Babies

$1,420.00

Ty Curly Beanie Baby Curly Bear Retired With Tag Errors Very Rare Free Shipping

Ty Curly Beanie Baby Curly Bear Retired With Tag Errors Very Rare Free Shipping

$2,200.00

Beanie Baby - Kicks -very Rare Versionerrortags

Beanie Baby - Kicks -very Rare Versionerrortags

$2,200.00

Mint Beanie Babies Ty Hippity Origiinal 1996 Very Rare With Many Tag Errors

Mint Beanie Babies Ty Hippity Origiinal 1996 Very Rare With Many Tag Errors

$2,200.00

Rare Mint Mystic Beanie Baby Errors Certificate Of Authenticity By Peggy G.

Rare Mint Mystic Beanie Baby Errors Certificate Of Authenticity By Peggy G.

$2,200.00

Rare Ty Beanie Babybabies Peace Bear Original Collectible With Tag Errors Pvc

Rare Ty Beanie Babybabies Peace Bear Original Collectible With Tag Errors Pvc

$2,200.00

Ty Beanie Baby Spot The Dog Rare With Errors

Ty Beanie Baby Spot The Dog Rare With Errors

$2,200.00

Original Princess Diana Of Wales Indonesia 1997 Bear Authentic Retired Rare

Original Princess Diana Of Wales Indonesia 1997 Bear Authentic Retired Rare

$2,200.00

The End Bear - Beanie Baby - Retiredrare - Mint Condition

The End Bear - Beanie Baby - Retiredrare - Mint Condition

$2,200.00

Beanie Baby The End Rare 1999 Retired Werrors

Beanie Baby The End Rare 1999 Retired Werrors

$2,200.00

1996 Peace Tye-dye Bear Ty Beanie Baby Rare Retired Pvc Multipletag Errors Mwmt

1996 Peace Tye-dye Bear Ty Beanie Baby Rare Retired Pvc Multipletag Errors Mwmt

$2,200.00

1st Edition Rare Tiny Version Princess P.e. Beanie Baby Errors Pale Green Stem

1st Edition Rare Tiny Version Princess P.e. Beanie Baby Errors Pale Green Stem

$2,199.99

Ty Beanie Babies Lot Of 20 Including Rare Peace Bear With Multiple Tag Errors

Ty Beanie Babies Lot Of 20 Including Rare Peace Bear With Multiple Tag Errors

$2,195.00

Retired Rare Gobbles 1996 Ty Beanie Baby Swing Tag

Retired Rare Gobbles 1996 Ty Beanie Baby Swing Tag

$2,188.00

Rare Retired Ty Beanie Baby Hoppity Pink Bunny W Tag Errors

Rare Retired Ty Beanie Baby Hoppity Pink Bunny W Tag Errors

$2,149.95

Millenium Beanie Baby Errors Very Rare.

Millenium Beanie Baby Errors Very Rare.

$1,500.00

Extremely Rare Millenium Beanie Baby - Errors Millennium

Extremely Rare Millenium Beanie Baby - Errors Millennium

$2,100.00

Htf-extremely Rare 1993 Valentino Ty Beanie Baby - Misspelled Tag And Pvc

Htf-extremely Rare 1993 Valentino Ty Beanie Baby - Misspelled Tag And Pvc

$2,090.00

Wrinkles The Bulldog Ty Beanie Baby. Rare, New, Mwmt, P.v.c. Pellets And Errors.

Wrinkles The Bulldog Ty Beanie Baby. Rare, New, Mwmt, P.v.c. Pellets And Errors.

$2,100.00

Extremely Rare Ty Beanie Baby Curly Retired Bear With Multi Errors, Make Offer

Extremely Rare Ty Beanie Baby Curly Retired Bear With Multi Errors, Make Offer

$2,100.00

Very Rare Retired Ty Beanie Baby - Garcia Pvc Misprint12 Errorsmwmt

Very Rare Retired Ty Beanie Baby - Garcia Pvc Misprint12 Errorsmwmt

$2,100.00

Ty Beanie Baby Claude-retired Rare

Ty Beanie Baby Claude-retired Rare

$2,100.00

Extremely Rare Ty Beanie Baby Claude The Crab, Retired Wmany Errors, Near Mint

Extremely Rare Ty Beanie Baby Claude The Crab, Retired Wmany Errors, Near Mint

$2,100.00

Ty Beanie Baby Garcia - 1995, Rare, Mint Condition P.v.c. Pellets

Ty Beanie Baby Garcia - 1995, Rare, Mint Condition P.v.c. Pellets

$2,100.00

Rare Ty Beanie Babies Ty Original Batty W Tag Errors

Rare Ty Beanie Babies Ty Original Batty W Tag Errors

$2,100.00

Rare Ty Beanie Baby Peace Bear Original Collectible With All Tag Errors

Rare Ty Beanie Baby Peace Bear Original Collectible With All Tag Errors

$2,097.00

Ty Beanie Babies Rare Valentino And Valentina Errors Reduced

Ty Beanie Babies Rare Valentino And Valentina Errors Reduced

$2,095.00

Retired Ty Beanie Baby Patti The Platypus Rare Pvc Pellets And Errors

Retired Ty Beanie Baby Patti The Platypus Rare Pvc Pellets And Errors

$2,090.00

Super Rare Original Hoppity, 1996 Ty Beanie Baby. With All Error Tags

Super Rare Original Hoppity, 1996 Ty Beanie Baby. With All Error Tags

$2,050.00

Extra Rare Ty Hoppity Beanie Baby 1996 6 Tag Errors

Extra Rare Ty Hoppity Beanie Baby 1996 6 Tag Errors

$1,999.99

18 Rare Beanie Babies 1994-2000 In Mint Conditions In Cases

18 Rare Beanie Babies 1994-2000 In Mint Conditions In Cases

$2,000.00

Beanie Babies 1999 Mcdonalds International Lot -all 4 Rare Errors Nib Retired Ty

Beanie Babies 1999 Mcdonalds International Lot -all 4 Rare Errors Nib Retired Ty

$2,000.00

Rare Mint Condition 1st Edition P.v.c. 1997 Princess Diana Beanie Baby Retired

Rare Mint Condition 1st Edition P.v.c. 1997 Princess Diana Beanie Baby Retired

$2,000.00

Ultra Rare Pax Prototype Bernie Ty Beanie Baby Authenticated Mwmt Mq

Ultra Rare Pax Prototype Bernie Ty Beanie Baby Authenticated Mwmt Mq

$1,499.99

Nib Erin The Bear Ty Ronald Mcdonald Charities With Errors. Rare

Nib Erin The Bear Ty Ronald Mcdonald Charities With Errors. Rare

$1,999.00

Rare Errors Britannia The Bear Nib Ty Beanie Babies Ronald Mcdonald Charities

Rare Errors Britannia The Bear Nib Ty Beanie Babies Ronald Mcdonald Charities

$1,999.00

1993 Rare Mystic Beanie Baby Coarse Mane And Tail Iridescent Horn - Two Tag Error

1993 Rare Mystic Beanie Baby Coarse Mane And Tail Iridescent Horn - Two Tag Error

$1,999.00

Rare Mint Princess Diana 1997 Retired Beanie Baby

Rare Mint Princess Diana 1997 Retired Beanie Baby

$2,000.00

Beanie Babies Garcia The Bear Rare Misprint Swing Tag Pvc Beanie Baby

Beanie Babies Garcia The Bear Rare Misprint Swing Tag Pvc Beanie Baby

$2,000.00

Ty Beanie Baby Curly Bear Tag Error - Rare Brown Nose China 1996 P.e.pellets

Ty Beanie Baby Curly Bear Tag Error - Rare Brown Nose China 1996 P.e.pellets

$1,995.95

Rare With 4 Errors Vintage 1993 Ty Beanie Babies Allura Bear Stuffed Toy Plush

Rare With 4 Errors Vintage 1993 Ty Beanie Babies Allura Bear Stuffed Toy Plush

$2,000.00

Rare With 6 Errors Vintage 1993 Ty Beanie Babies Greyson Stuffed Toy Plush Attic

Rare With 6 Errors Vintage 1993 Ty Beanie Babies Greyson Stuffed Toy Plush Attic

$2,000.00

Rare With 3 Errors Vintage 1998 Ty Beanie Babies Mac Stuffed Toy Plush Cardinal

Rare With 3 Errors Vintage 1998 Ty Beanie Babies Mac Stuffed Toy Plush Cardinal

$1,999.99

Beanie Babies Collections Rover Rare With Errors

Beanie Babies Collections Rover Rare With Errors

$2,000.00

Very Rare Mac Beanie Baby With Errors Near Mint

Very Rare Mac Beanie Baby With Errors Near Mint

$2,000.00

Ty Beanie Baby Hissy With Rare

Ty Beanie Baby Hissy With Rare

$2,000.00

Rare 1st Edition Princess Diana. Pe Beanie Baby, No Space

Rare 1st Edition Princess Diana. Pe Beanie Baby, No Space

$2,000.00

Halo Retired Beanie Baby Rare No Tag

Halo Retired Beanie Baby Rare No Tag

$2,000.00

1993 Valentino Beanie Baby Rare

1993 Valentino Beanie Baby Rare

$2,000.00

Valentina Beanie Baby Rare With Tag Errors In Mint Condition

Valentina Beanie Baby Rare With Tag Errors In Mint Condition

$2,000.00

Rare Ty 1997 Employee Beanie Baby Bear Good Condition

Rare Ty 1997 Employee Beanie Baby Bear Good Condition

$2,000.00

Ty Beanie Baby Iggy And Rainbow Recalled Rare Many Errors

Ty Beanie Baby Iggy And Rainbow Recalled Rare Many Errors

$2,000.00

Rare Princess Beanie Baby 1997 Mem. Fund, China, Spaced, Tush P.e. With Stamp

Rare Princess Beanie Baby 1997 Mem. Fund, China, Spaced, Tush P.e. With Stamp

$2,000.00

Extremely Rare Ty Beanie Babies Peace Bear With Tag Errors Pvc

Extremely Rare Ty Beanie Babies Peace Bear With Tag Errors Pvc

$2,000.00

Price Comparison

Item NameStatusDate EndedLabeled
Peace Ty Beanie Baby-rare-retired-rainbow With Cubbie CubeSOLD09/29/2017Retired
Limited Edition Rare Ty Princess Diana Beanie Baby No Space No Number With GiftSOLD10/08/2017Princess Diana
Extremely Rare Errors Ty Beanie Babies Peace Bear With Tag RetiredSOLD08/21/2017Retired
Ty #1 Rep Bear No Emblem Oddity Mwmt Mq Ty Beanie Baby Rare AuthenticatedSOLD09/05/2017Retired
***very Rare*** Ty Beanie Baby Peace Bear With Multiple Tag Errors SOLD09/29/2017Retired
Extremely Rare Ty Beanie Baby 'curly' Retired Bear With Many Errors-mint-gem!!!SOLD08/20/2017Retired
Extremely Rare Errors Ty Beanie Babies Peace Bear Retired With TagSOLD09/24/2017Retired
Rare Claude The Crab Ty Beanie Baby With Errors 1996 MintSOLD10/04/2017Retired
Ultra Rare Authenticated Ty 1st Gen Mwmt Mq! Tan Inky Without Mouth Beanie BabySOLD08/19/2017Retired
Extremely Rare! 1st Valentino 1993 Ty Inc Beanie Baby Swing Tag Errors Pvc SOLD09/05/2017Retired
Extremely Rare! Valentino 1993/1994 Ty Beanie Baby With 17 Errors! Obo!SOLD08/08/2017Retired
Rare 1st. Edition (1997) Ty Princess Diana Bear New China Pvc No SpaceSOLD09/09/2017Retired
Extremely Rare! Valentino 1993/1994 Ty Beanie Baby With Tag ErrorsSOLD09/12/2017Retired
Ty Princess Diana Ghost Authenticated Indo.- Pvc - Space Super Rare! SOLD08/21/2017Retired
Rare Ty Beanie Baby Royal Blue Peanut The Elephant Certificate Of AuthenticitySOLD08/13/2017Retired
Peanut Royal Blue Elephant Rare Ty Beanie Babies Baby 3rd Gen Tag 1995 OriginalSOLD10/18/2017Retired
Authenticated Ty Beanie Baby ~ultra Rare 1st Gen Ally~SOLD08/18/2017Retired
Lot Of 415+ Original Ty Beanie Babies All With Tags Some Rare & RetiredSOLD09/03/2017Retired
Ty Beanie Baby Very Rare - Seaweed The OtterSOLD08/12/2017Retired
Ty Series Iii ~silver Manny & Splash~ Rare Beanie Babies Card ~ Low ##SOLD09/30/2017Trading Cards
Massive Lot Of 300+ Ty Beanie Babies/buddies Inc- Rare & Retired! Free ShippingSOLD07/27/2017Retired
Huge Lot Of Over 110 Beanie Boos Several Rare Included Large And SmallSOLD09/19/2017Retired
Ty Beanie Babies >> Glory The Bear >> Rare 1996 W/ Tag Errors >> Very [email protected]@l!!SOLD09/17/2017Retired
Authenticated Billionaire Bear #3 Mwmt Mq Ty Beanie Baby - Rare BeanieSOLD08/14/2017Retired
Ty Beanie Baby, Peanut, Very Rare,dark Blue And Light BlueSOLD10/09/2017Retired
Ultra Rare Authenticated Ty Beanie Baby Slither 1st Gen Hang Tag True Blue BeansSOLD08/23/2017Retired
Ty Beanie Boo Peanut The Elephant W/ Hang Tag - Solid Eyes - Extremely RareSOLD08/29/2017Retired
Ty Teeny Tys Chaser X Lizard Ultra Rare Hard To Find Limited Edition SOLD09/18/2017Retired
Ty Teeny Tys Chaser X Lizard Ultra Rare Hard To Find Limited Edition SOLD09/22/2017Retired
Ty Beanie Babies Royal Blue Peanut The Elephant 3rd Gen 1st Tush 4062 Rare 1995SOLD08/12/2017Retired
Ty Beanie Babies Dark Blue Peanut The Elephant Third Generation Hang Tag RareSOLD08/01/2017Retired
Authenticated Billionaire Bear #5 Mwmt Mq Ty Beanie Babies - Rare #739 Of 769SOLD09/15/2017Retired
Rare Peanut The Royal Blue Elephant Ty Beanie Babies Baby 3rd Gen Hang Tag 1995SOLD09/30/2017Retired
Ty Beanie Babies Royal Blue Peanut The Elephant 3rd Gen 1st Tush 4062 Rare 1993SOLD08/12/2017Retired
Authenticated Mwmt Korean Magic 3rd/kor 1st/ce Gen "ultra Rare - Mq"SOLD07/23/2017Retired
1998 Ty Rare Peanut Royal Blue Elephant Beanie Baby SOLD08/01/2017Retired
Old Face And New Face Cranberry Teddys ~ Ty Beanie Baby ~ Authentic, Rare, MintSOLD10/16/2017Retired
Peanut Royal Blue Elephant Rare Ty Beanie Babies Baby 3rd Gen Tag 1995 OriginalSOLD10/11/2017Retired
Ty Beanie Boo 6" Slush Husky Mwmt (one Time Uk Shipment) **very Rare** #36006 SOLD10/11/2017Current
Brand New Lot Of 188 4th Generation Ty Beanie Babies Few Duplicates Retired RareSOLD08/24/2017Retired